I decided to research further, turning to two ever trustworthy Australian cooking icons - Margaret Fulton and Stephanie Alexander. Their instructions both started off with a stirred custard cooked on the stovetop. This seemed to me less than authentic (but perhaps it isn't), and even to be cheating a little. Nope, I wanted the cook-in-a-water-bath-in-the-oven recipe. Many recipes had the exact same cream to eggs ratio George's recipe employs - 100ml of cream to 1 egg. Some others had a substantially higher proportion of eggs to cream - 8 egg yolks to 500 or 600ml of cream - but wouldn't that be too eggy flavoured? I decided to go ahead and use George's recipe, adding an extra yolk, 6 ramekins and venting the foil. It is in the oven now, and so far is looking like a fail :( . It has not set in the specified 30 mins, and we are now up to about 50 mins and it isn't even close to setting. I am feeling pretty disappointed and lacking in confidence, when a baked custard has never scared me off before. I will keep cooking it, and might turn the temp up and remove the foil top to see if that helps, but if it still won't set, I am going to go back and look at Margaret Fulton's recipe and Stephanie Alexander's recipe, and go with whichever of these sounds better and just do the stovetop method in the hope of having something I can serve to my visitors.
Hmmm... the custards are officially a fail. After spending more than double the time specified in the recipe, and still being incredibly runny, I got sick of checking every 5-10 mins, so I took the foil off, turned the heat up to 140C, and left them to it. They finally set, but I think I left them too long, and the custard has split a bit. Thank goodness it was only a trial run! Now debating whether to do the stovetop method, or make something else entirely for Wednesday... Decisions, decisions...
Now, I was very tempted not to post any photos of my failed attempt, but I think I gave it a good shot, and there must be something missing in the recipe's instructions. Surely so many people wouldn't end up with unset custards unless there was something missing in the recipe?
Beaten egg yolks and caster sugar - in the segment, George says the lighter the yolk mixture, the better the custard will be, but I have my doubts about that. I think I took this advice too far, as my custard mixture was frothy.
Scalded cream and vanilla beans seeds - love the speckle of vanilla bean seeds :). I brought the cream to just under boiling point, because my understanding is if you boil the milk, you alter the proteins needed for the custard to set.
The uncooked custard after the cream had been added to the yolk mixture - definitely too frothy, unless I was making a milkshake.
The uncooked custards sitting in their water bath.
Covered with foil but vented over the custards - I also left the sides loose so that there wouldn't be too much steam accumulating under the foil to drip condensation back onto the custards.
Cooked custard - still soft in texture, and the mixture has split.